Carbide-based PVC resin can replace ethylene-based resin in most general-purpose products, pipe and profile above all, once a trial on your own line confirms the formulation still runs. Stay on ethylene-based resin for clear film, medical and pharmaceutical products, and any customer who requires a mercury-free supply chain or will not accept carbide-route material.
Is Carbide-Based PVC the Same Polymer as Ethylene-Based PVC
Yes. Both routes polymerize vinyl chloride monomer (VCM), so the resin has the same chain; the route only changes how the VCM was made and which traces travel with it into the reactor.
At the end of 2024, the carbide route held 74% of China’s PVC capacity; outside China, PVC is made almost entirely by the ethylene route.
Where the Two Resins Differ
The documented differences are in lot-to-lot consistency and in residues. Test fusion behaviour and mechanical properties such as tensile strength, elongation and impact on your own line.
A 2024 paper in the China Chlor-Alkali industry journal, written by engineers at a carbide-route producer, reports that carbide monomer quality makes large reactors prone to swings in impurity count, bulk density, particle size distribution and viscosity number, with volatiles prone to fail specification.
The grade comparisons below use our own spec sheets. SG is a grade name and does not identify the route on its own: a sheet tells you the route only when it names the producer.
Distribución del peso molecular
No published data we could find shows that carbide-route resin has a wider molecular weight distribution than ethylene-route resin at the same K value.
Average molecular weight is something you choose by Valor K, and both routes cover the same range: our carbide-route SG3 is specified at K71–72 (average degree of polymerization 1251–1370), and our ethylene-route S-1300 at K71–73 (degree of polymerization 1250–1350).
The swings in viscosity number reported for carbide-route production in large reactors mean the K value of carbide-route lots can vary more from lot to lot around the nominal grade. If your process is sensitive to small K shifts, run the trial on more than one lot.
Impurezas residuales
On published spec sheets, carbide-route resin carries no residue that ethylene-route resin is not also limited for. The measurable difference is a higher allowance for volatile matter, and the open question is mercury from the mercury chloride catalyst that Chinese carbide-route plants usually use.
The figures below are specification maxima from our sheets, not measured lots.
| Property (maximum) | Carbide route, SG3–SG8 | Ethylene route, S-series |
|---|---|---|
| Residual VCM, µg/g | 5 | 5 (S-700, S-1000); 2.0 superior / 5.0 qualified (S-1300) |
| 1,1-dichloroethane, food grade, mg/kg | 150 | 150 (S-700, S-1000) |
| Volatile matter incl. water, % | 0.30 (SG3); 0.40 (SG5, SG7, SG8) | 0.20 superior / 0.30 qualified (S-1300) |
| Impurity particles, count | 16 (SG3, SG5); 20 (SG7, SG8) | 16 superior / 60 qualified (S-1300) |
1,1-dichloroethane is often called a carbide-route marker, yet our ethylene-route S-700 and S-1000 carry the same 150 mg/kg food-grade limit, so its presence on a sheet does not identify the route.
Whether that mercury survives into the finished resin at a measurable level is not settled by any published data we could verify. Do not assume either answer; if mercury matters to your customer, treat it as a supply-chain requirement.
Heat Stability and Whiteness
No published data we could find shows the route changing heat stability, and at K60–62 our carbide-route and ethylene-route grades are held to the same whiteness floor after 160 °C for 10 minutes.
Our carbide-route SG7 and ethylene-route S-800 both specify whiteness of at least 75%. That is a floor, so measure whiteness on the lots you trial.
Where Carbide-Based Resin Can Replace Ethylene-Based Resin
Carbide-based resin can replace ethylene-based resin in rigid pipe and fittings, profiles and window frames, and general-purpose rigid sheet, and in general-purpose flexible compounds such as cable insulation, flooring and coated fabric where no customer specification ties you to the route.
On 24 April 2025, FOB China ethylene-based PVC was assessed at $620/mt against $600/mt for carbide-based PVC.
For flexible work, the plasticizer absorption floors are close at matching K value: our carbide-route SG3 specifies at least 26 g per 100 g resin, against at least 27 g for ethylene-route S-1300.
In every case the substitution holds only after a trial on your existing formulation confirms stabilizer and lubricant levels and fusion behaviour.
Where Ethylene-Based Resin Is Still Needed
Stay on ethylene-based resin for transparent film and sheet, medical tubing, pharmaceutical blister packaging and similar products whose approval names a resin grade and producer, and for any customer who requires a mercury-free supply chain.
In these products a qualified grade cannot be swapped without requalifying the end product, and our clarity grade for transparent film, S-800, is ethylene-route.
China still uses mercury chloride as a catalyst in acetylene-based VCM, while ethylene-based VCM production uses none, and the EU has prohibited mercury in VCM production since 1 January 2022. That EU rule governs making VCM inside the EU and is not, on its text, a ban on importing carbide-route resin. The Minamata Convention has set no global phase-out date yet, so a mercury-free requirement comes from a customer’s or programme’s own specification.
Buyers in Latin America accept carbide-based PVC less readily than ethylene-based, and traders do not always say which route a Chinese offer comes from, so confirm the producer before you quote a customer who has a preference.